Attaboy
Venue Brief
Menu-free Lower East Side cocktail bar on the old Milk & Honey site, where bartenders build each drink to order and keep pouring until 3am every night.
Venue Details
- Vibe
- IntimateUpbeatDate Night
- Age guide
- 25-45
- Dress code
- Casual Chic
- Demographic
- Young ProfessionalsLocalsCouples
- Music genre
- Old School HitsRock
- Price
- $$$$
- Open season
- Year-round
- Clientele
- LocalsAmerican
- Offerings
- Table Service
- Open times
- Mon 5 PM – 3 AMTue 5 PM – 3 AMWed 5 PM – 3 AMThu 5 PM – 3 AM BestFri 5 PM – 3 AM BusySat 5 PM – 3 AM BusySun 5 PM – 3 AM
- Vibe score
- 8.4 / 10
Address
Contact
About Attaboy
There is no menu at 134 Eldridge Street. Guests name a spirit, a mood or a flavor, and the bartender builds something around it, usually a riff on a classic, at about $25 a drink. Sam Ross and Michael McIlroy opened the bar in the former Milk & Honey space, and Ross is the creator of the Penicillin and the Paper Plane, two modern classics regulars still order here. The room is narrow and candlelit, one long bar under a row of bare bulbs, with a tailor's sign still on the door. It opens at 5pm and runs to 3am seven nights a week, which makes it a late-night stop as much as a first round, and it fills quickly. Monthly cocktail classes, including Negroni sessions led by Ross, draw glowing reviews. It placed 37th on North America's 50 Best Bars for 2026 and holds 4.2 from roughly 2,000 Google reviews.

